Tuesday, September 3, 2013

BREAKING NEWS: California Adds Exotic Species To State List; ABA To Follow Suit?

UPDATE 9/4: From California Bird Wizard Kimball Garrett on CALBIRDS, "Nutmeg Mannikin (Lonchura punctulata) is added by acceptance of a package of information (CBRC #2013-085) showing that it has met the CBRC's criteria for addition to the California state list as an introduced species. It represents a new family (Estrildidae: Estrildid finches) for the California list and is placed at the end of the list following House Sparrow. Note that the name "Nutmeg Mannikin" is not the English name used in most of the native range of this species, and it is possible that the name will be changed by the AOU to "Scaly-breasted Munia" in the future. Also, the ABA Checklist Committee is currently voting on the addition of Nutmeg Mannikin to the ABA list, with a decision due very soon. "

Of course, I think we all know how the ABA Checklist Committee is going to vote, since CBRC member Jon Dunn is currently on the board, and another living legend from California (Paul Lehman) is on the board as well. You heard it here first dweebs.


THIS JUST IN: The dreaded Nutmeg Mannikin has been added to California's official state list by the California Bird Records Committee (aka Bird Police). Not only is this earth-shaking, pants-wetting news for the numerous hardcore state and county listers that reside in California, this courageous decision has implications for the entire nation.

The American Birding Association will most certainly be someday adding this bird onto their list in the future (perhaps many years, perhaps much sooner), making it officially "countable". If you are a lister who plays by their rules, you would be interested to know that once a state committee adds an exotic species onto the official list, the ABA inevitably adds it as well, although it can take a long time. I don't think there are any current exceptions to this pattern. Keep in mind that Nutmeg Mannikin, Scaly-breasted Munia, Spotted Munia and Spice Finch are all different names for the same bird; the CBRC lists them as Nutmeg Mannikin.

Of course, those birders who refuse to list introduced species of any sort ("NIB or Death", or something like that) will be unimpressed. Haters gonna hate.

The effect mannikins (native to a large swath of Asia) have on native California birds is unknown. Like many invasive species, they are fond of places not far from human development...at least they are not a brood parasite like another fellow SoCal invader, the Pin-tailed Whydah. Southwestern California is the place to get this bird; they are most often encountered in weedy and unpleasant habitats in San Diego, Orange, Riverside, Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties. Adjust your travel plans accordingly.

Thanks to Dave Pereksta for the photo.


  1. Tucker, there aren't any California county birders that count introduced birds. Nutmeg Manakin = yawn...

    1. Hate to break it to you Fowler, but not every county lister plays by the rules of Herr Sterling! Now is also a good time to learn how to spell "mannikin" ;)

    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    3. I'll just call it a munia, then. ;) Who doesn't play by the rules? They shall be burned at the stake with Herr Sterling in the front watching and also videoed and exposed to all CA County Birders for the IB Counter they are! Bastards!

  2. Does this include the Nutmeg Manakins that have been breeding in Alameda Park, Alameda County for years.